Wanscher O (1877)

Om Diphteritis og Croup - særligt med hensyn til Tracheostomien ved samme. [On diphtheria and croup - especially regarding tracheostomy in this condition]. Disputats [Thesis]. Jacob Lund: Kjøbenhavn, p 67-68.

Title page(s)


Key passage(s)



“If any surgeon with material as large as chief physician Holmer could really take the decision, as a test, to let every second croup patient (with an indication for tracheotomy) remain without the operation and every second undergo the operation, and it turned out that the proportion of unoperated [patients who] recovered was equal to or higher than those operated [on], then one could begin to doubt the value of tracheotomy; but before two such equivalent statistics on 1) croup treated expectantly and 2) croup treated operatively become available, one may reasonably assume that tracheotomy saves a number of percentage points of children, who during expectant or medical treatment would have died from suffocation.

When the severity of dyspnoea has indicated the [need for the] operation, then (at least during the last couple of years) no contraindication [to surgery] has been accepted in the 1st department at the Kommunehospitalet; irrespective of the low chances of a satisfactory final result, the operation has been performed despite severe intoxication, young age, pneumonia, or other complications.”

Translation by Christian Gluud

JLL Book of EssaysHave you read the James Lind Library's Introduction to Fair Tests of Treatments?

We have edited, updated and abridged all of the Essays from the Library for 2019, and lavishly illustrated them with examples from the history of fair tests of treatments.  Share and enjoy!

Download the PDF