Middleton J (2008). Pellagra and the blues song ‘Cornbread, meat and black molasses’.
Email to someoneTweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookPin on PinterestShare on LinkedIn

© John Middleton, Sandwell Primary Care Trust, 438 High Street, West Bromwich, West Midlands B70 9LD, UK. Email: middletonjohn1955@gmail.com


Cite as: Middleton J (2008). Pellagra and the blues song ‘Cornbread, meat and black molasses’. JLL Bulletin: Commentaries on the history of treatment evaluation (http://www.jameslindlibrary.org/articles/pellagra-and-the-blues-song-cornbread-meat-and-black-molasses/)


In his book Blues fell this morning’ Paul Oliver, the celebrated historian and biographer of the blues, describes a conversation with Sonny Terry, the blind virtuoso blues harmonica player. Cornbread, meat and black molasses was a ‘field holler’ – a song sung by prison farm inmates on hard labour field detail.

Boy, I’m gonna tell ya about this song – now this is a chain gang song. And now the boys on the chain gang, don’t eat, they don’t feed on nothin’ but cornbread, meat and molasses.

‘Cornbread, beans and black molasses’ can be downloaded here as an mp3.


Prisoners – black and white – across the Deep South of the United States were aware of Joseph Goldberger’s experiments (see Goldberger et al. 1923Morabia 2006), which were designed to find the cause of pellagra by assessing and modifying the diets of prisoners at Rankin Prison Farm, Mississippi. The archives of the State of Mississippi hold evidence of the extensive public controversy, involving outraged victims of the crimes of these inmates, the general public and Governor Brewer, who had sanctioned Goldberger’s experiment and the offer of pardon to the volunteers.

In the early 1900s, pellagra affected an estimated 50,000 people in the southern USA, and killed 7000 poor blacks and whites. Goldberger believed that pellagra was caused by a dietary deficiency, not by an infection, as was widely believed. He was so strong in this belief that he had tested the hypothesis on himself, his wife and other members of the American public health service. To test the assumed infectiousness of pellagra, they had variously inoculated themselves with skin squames and nasal secretions and eaten faeces from pellagrins.

Goldberger’s experiments feeding volunteer prisoners cornbread, fat meat and black molasses induced pellagra, which was alleviated by variations including peas, beans, cabbage greens, and wheat bread. By 1926, Goldberger proposed yeast extract supplements to combat the disease and arranged distribution through the Red Cross Stores that were supplying food handouts, canned grapefruit juice (vitamin C – in Champion Jack Dupree’s Warehouseman Blues), clothes and blankets.

This dietary support did reduce the frequency of pellagra. However, poor blacks felt stigmatized by handouts and The Red Cross stores themselves carried a bitter reputation. Oliver describes how, after the great floods of 1927, ‘Negroes who entered the Red Cross food stations were seized and put into forced labour…Negro refugees under armed guards did the entire work on the Vicksburg levees and the treatment of the suffering homeless people was less than human’. Many did not return from this latter day slavery.  Many collapsed exhausted, to be buried in the earth mounds of the great river – hence, in Red Cross Store Blues, Alabama Sam sings:

She talked last night talked for an hour, Go get a sack of that Red Cross flour.
I told her nooh, I don’t wanna go. I said, I cannot go down to the Red Cross Store.
But you know the government takin’ a change, say they gonna treat everybody right. They gonna give them two cans of beans and one little can of tripe.
I told her no….

Leadbelly and Mississippi Fred McDowell have also sung the song; the words vary, with some versions alluding to another blight on the Red Cross Stores – their association with military recruitment stations for the World Wars.

Goldberger’s courageous research was eventually rewarded when mass supplementation of cornbread flour with yeast extract eradicated pellagra. The pellagra preventing agent was niacin. Although the niacin molecule had been isolated by Weidel in 1873, its role in preventing pellagra was not identified until 1937, by Conrad Elvehjem.

This James Lind Library commentary has been republished in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 2008;101:569-570. Print PDF

References

Goldberger J, Waring CH, Tanner WF (1923). Pellagra prevention by diet among inmates. Pub Hlth Rep 38:2361-68.

Morabia A (2006). Joseph Goldberger’s research on the prevention of pellagra. The James Lind Library (www.jameslindlibrary.org).

Oliver P (1963). Blues fell this morning: the meaning of the Blues. London: the Jazz Book Club/Cassell.

Roe DA (1973). A plague of corn: the social history of pellagra. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

Note

Cornbread, beans and black molasses can be heard on the album Doctor write me a prescription for the blues by  Doctor Harp’s Medicine Band. Sales of the album raise funds for Birmingham Children’s Hospital Charity. It is available from  info@drharp.co.uk  and from Birmingham Children’s Hospital Charitable Trust (tel: 0044 121 333 8525) for £10 plus £1.50 p&p., as well as from the i-tunes blues collection.