Half a century ago, a diagnosis of leukemia in a child was considered a death sentence. Today, approximately 85% of children diagnosed with this once fatal disease are cured (Pui et al. 2009; US National Institutes of Health 2010). The discovery that ushered in this dramatically transformed outlook was the observation by Sidney Farber (1903–1973) and his colleagues in Boston in 1948 that drugs that acted against the vitamin folic acid could produce remissions in children with acute leukemia (Farber et al. 1948). While carefully controlled studies were required to develop therapeutic regimens developed from these initial observations (Pocock 1977; Peto et al. 1986), the Farber article is featured in the James Lind Library because it is an example of a treatment effect that is so dramatic that bias can be confidently ruled out as an explanation for the observations (Glasziou et al. 2007). What led to the landmark findings in 1948, and what evidence was published subsequently confirming that a major advance in treatment had been discovered?
Gordon Piller (2001) reviewed the history of leukemia, which means ‘white blood’ in Greek. In 1811, Cullen reported a case of ‘splenitis acutus in which the serum of the blood drawn from the arm had the appearance of milk’ (Cullen 1811). A spate of more detailed reports appeared in the 1840s — in Paris (Donné 1844), Edinburgh (Craigie 1845; Bennett 1845), Berlin (Virchow 1845), and London (Fuller 1846). Symptoms included fever, enlarged spleen, swollen lymph nodes, and a proliferation of ‘purulent matter and lymph’ (Craigie 1845) in the blood that, under a microscope, showed a ‘large number of colourless granular, spheroidal globules varying in size’ (Fuller 1850) crowding out red blood cells. Fuller’s 1850 account was of a case of pediatric leukemia. In an article about 35 suspected cases of leukemia, John Hughes Bennett (1812–1875), a British pathologist at the Royal Infirmary in Edinburgh and a microscopist, included the first known illustrations of blood cells from a leukemic patient (Bennett 1852).
Two decades passed before a basic scientific understanding of the mechanisms of leukemia emerged. Ernst Neumann (1834–1918) at the Pathological Institute at Konigsberg and Giulio Bizzozero (1846–1901) at the University of Turin independently reported that blood cells originate in the bone marrow (Neumann 1868; 1869; 1870; Bizzozero 1868; 1869) and that leukemia is a disease of the bone marrow (Neumann 1872). These groundbreaking discoveries would not be generally accepted until the end of the 19th century; and even then, they were not reflected in treatments for leukemia, which continued to include the use of leeches and arsenic. Notes from a presentation on leukemia to the Medical Society of London reflects this discouraging state of affairs (Carpenter 1880):
There is something wanting in the present plan … members of the medical profession are continually trying processes for the cure of diseases which have been shown to be useless, and the textbooks continue to recommend medicines which have never done any good.
Apart from this therapeutic stagnation, the work of Neumann and Bizzozero, as well as that of Paul Erlich (1854–1915), began to illuminate leukemia’s etiology. Erhlich invented novel staining methods for the study of the nucleus and cytoplasm of blood cells and classified leukemia as myelogenous or lymphocytic (Ehrlich 1877; 1880).
Following Röntgen’s discovery of X-rays in 1895, experimental X-ray treatments led to some very short-term suppression of tumors and tumor shrinkage, but with no reported improvement in prognosis. Furthermore, there was no evidence that these novel radiation therapies had any useful effects on acute leukemias (Minot et al. 1924), which continued to be ‘insidious, rapid, and progressive’ (Buchanan 1909) and rapidly fatal (Forkner 1938; Burchenal and Murphy 1965). Between 1926 and 1947, only 3 of 150 adult and pediatric patients with acute leukemias treated at New York’s Memorial Hospital survived for a year, and none lived beyond 14 months (Southam et al. 1951). A review of more than 200 untreated cases of acute pediatric leukemia from this period found that median survival, from the first symptom to death, was 3.9 months (Tivey 1952). Before 1950, childhood leukemia was termed ‘acute leukemia’ and the sub-classifications of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) and acute myeloid leukemia (AML) were treated as the same clinical entity — with approximately 4 in 5 being ALL type, the same proportion as today (Simone 2006).
Discovery of the effects of nitrogen mustard on cancer
One line of development of systemic treatments for cancer resulted from classified studies of the effect of nitrogen mustard derivatives on cancer tumors at Yale University, done under the aegis of the Office of Scientific Research and Development (OSRD) of the US Department of Defense (Papac 2001). Autopsies of soldiers killed in the First World War by sulfur mustard gas consistently revealed evidence of leukopenia and lymphoid hypoplasia in the victims. This association was confirmed in December 1943 when a Luftwaffe attack on 17 allied ships at Bari, Italy, aerosolized one hundred tons of sulfur mustard secretly held in a US Liberty ship. A US physician trained in chemical warfare, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander, was flown in from North Africa to investigate cases of acute conjunctivitis and dermatitis, and he found extreme leukopenia in those of the ship’s crew who had been exposed (Hirsch 2006).
After World War II, findings from the toxic release at Bari and wartime studies by the OSRD and others began to be shared and applied to experimental treatments of cancers (Alexander 1947; Gilman 1946; Goodman et al 1946; Jacobson, 1946; Rhoads 1946). Mustard agents caused brief remissions in several patients with advanced-stage Hodgkin lymphoma and non-Hodgkin lymphoma, and would later be found to effect dramatic remissions in patients with Hodgkin lymphoma (Merk 1948). Thus despite drug toxicity, the lethality of the diseases, and without knowledge of DNA’s role in replicating the mutant cells that these early treatments were beginning to block (National Academy of Sciences 2010), a scientific approach to targeting tumor cell growth in humans had been established. However, while these incipient chemical treatments showed promise in temporarily improving the prognoses of patients with lymphomas, there was no evidence that they had an impact in acute leukemias (Weatherall 2001). The search for treatments for the latter explored alternative strategies.
Folate: initial hopes and early disappointments
Lucy Wills (Bastian 2007), a British physician working in India in the 1930s, had found that extracts of yeast and liver reduced anemia and leukopenia in pregnant women. She also found that removing this anti-anemic (so-called ‘Wills factor’) from the diet of monkeys led to a severe reduction in their red and white blood cells (Wills 1937; Jukes 1987). Wills’ discovery of what would come to be known as folate or folic acid set off a competitive search among several pharmaceutical research laboratories to isolate and synthesize it (Pfiffner et al. 1943; Stokstad 1943). A team led by Yellapragada SubbaRow (1895–1948) at the American Cyanamid Company identified folic acid’s structure and was the first to synthesize it (Angier et al. 1945; SubbaRow et al. 1946), and several early animal studies of folic acid’s effects on tumor growth indicated that it might induce tumor regression (Lewisohn et al. 1944; Leuchtenberger et al. 1945).
Sidney Farber (then assistant professor of pathology at Harvard Medical School and pathologist-in-chief at the Children’s Medical Center Boston), Louis Diamond (assistant professor of pediatrics at Harvard Medical School and a hematologist and physician at the Children’s Medical Center), and their three research assistants administered folic acid from SubbaRow’s laboratory to 90 patients with late-stage cancers, including acute leukemia. Contrary to predictions based on the preclinical research, they found that folic acid actually accelerated the leukemic process to an unprecedented degree, leading to sudden mortality in all patients. Farber concluded that folic acid conjugates should not be used to treat patients with cancer (Farber et al. 1947). Importantly, however, he inferred from the observed ‘acceleration phenomenon’ that reducing folic acid levels might suppress proliferation of malignant cells and restore normal bone marrow function.
Identifying the effects of antifolates
At Farber’s request, SubbaRow’s team developed a series of antifolates (folic acid antagonists), including aminopterin (Seegers et al. 1947), and found that these disturbed the metabolism of leukemic cells in chickens and mice, an effect that could then be reversed by administering folic acid (Franklin et al. 1947; Hutchings et al. 1947). Encouraged by this evidence, the Farber team began, on 16 December 1947, daily administration of the antifolate aminopterin to a critically ill 8-year-old boy with acute leukemia and a 106ºF temperature. Four months later, the disease was in clinical and hematological remission, and the boy was reported to be in ‘excellent physical condition.’
Farber and his colleagues went on to study 16 critically ill children with acute leukemia. They monitored each patient carefully, adjusting the daily dose of aminopterin within a range of 0.25 to 1.0 mg, and stopping altogether when crude liver extract failed to mitigate the adverse effects of folic acid depletion. Among the 16 children receiving this novel agent, 10 had unprecedented remissions in the weeks and months following treatment; 2 did not experience remission and 4 died within a few months.
Farber and his team documented the events surrounding 5 of the 10 children exhibiting the ‘best results that we have observed’ (Farber et al. 1948) and demonstrated for the first time that it was possible to suppress proliferation of malignant cells and to restore normal bone-marrow function in children with acute leukemia. They emphasized that these profound changes were temporary and were accompanied by serious drug-related side effects, including stomatosis, ulceration of the mucous membrane of the mouth, internal hemorrhage, and depletion of the bone marrow leading to aplasia. In a follow-up article published in 1949, Farber offered further evidence of these dramatic effects in a study of ‘approximately 60’ other children with acute leukemia treated either with aminopterin or with one of two closely related antifolate agents (amethopterin – now known as methotrexate – and amino-an-fol). More than half of these patients experienced important remissions, similar to those seen in the 10 patients in the first study, with periods of survival well beyond expectation. But Farber remained cautious (Farber 1949):
Despite the increasing number of patients in whom temporary remissions have been produced, with survival in some far beyond the usual course of disease, no evidence has been presented which would justify use of the word “cure” of acute leukemia. … Further research for less toxic related compounds with even greater effectiveness is not only justified by these studies but is imperative. The value of this direction of research in cancer has been established.
Farber’s 1948 watershed findings were met initially with strong skepticism (Dana-Farber 2010). However, 16 and 23 months after the onset of their disease, two of the five patients described in the 1948 article remained alive with their leukemia ‘under control’, and this had led to ‘widespread use of aminopterin in the treatment of acute leukemia’ (Farber 1949).
Several other investigators initiated clinical trials of antifolates’, also called ‘antimetabolites’, so named because they inhibit metabolic processes, including cell division. William Dameshek (1900-1969) and his research team at the New England Medical Center at Tufts University reported remissions in 10 out of 32 patients with leukemia who were treated with an antifolate for at least a week; and these included remission in an adult with leukemia. Although Dameshek appreciated the short-term effects of these novel cancer treatments, like Farber, he did not make premature claims that survival would necessarily be affected:
It appears that the folic acid antagonists, although by no means curative in acute leukemia, offer the first ray of hope in the treatment of this disease and may be the precursors of more effective and less toxic drugs. Thus, the results of therapy may be said to represent the beginning of a new era in the therapy of this dread disease. They also lend support to the thesis that in chemotherapy may lie the fate of the ultimate control of cancer and related diseases (Dameshek et al. 1950).
In the decades following Farber’s first study with antifolates in children with acute leukemia, chemotherapies would prove to be critical in the development of effective cancer treatments, and of some cures. To this day a residual compound from Farber’s study, methotrexate, which has comparable effectiveness but fewer adverse effects than aminopterin, remains a standard component of the treatment of acute lymphoblastic leukemia, and a key agent in combination therapies for many other cancers.
This James Lind Library commentary has been republished in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 2011;105:177-181. Print PDF
Alexander SF (1947). Medical reports on the Bari harbor mustard casualties. Military Surgeon 101:2-17.
Angier RB, Boothe JH, Hutchings BL, Mowat JH, Semb J, Stokstad EL, SubbaRow Y, Waller CW, Cosulich DB, Fahrenbach MJ, Hultquist ME, Kuh E, Northey EH, Seeger DR, Sickels JP, Smith JM (1945). Synthesis of a compound identical with the L. Casei factor isolated from liver. Science 102:227-228.
Bastian H (2007). Lucy Wills (1888-1964), the life and research of an adventurous independent woman. JLL Bulletin: Commentaries on the history of treatment evaluation (www.jameslindlibrary.org).
Bennett JH (1845). Case of hypertrophy of the spleen and liver in which death took place from suppuration of the blood. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 64:413-423.
Bennett JH (1852). Leucocythemia or white cell blood. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 72:7-82.
Bizzozero G (1868). Sulla funzione ematopoetica del midollo delle ossa. Centralblatt Medizinische Wissenschaften 6:885.
Bizzozero G (1869). Sulla funzione ematopoetica del midollo delle ossa, seconda communicazione preventia. Centralblatt Medizinische Wissenschaften 10:149-150.
Buchanan RJM (1909). The blood in health and disease. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Burchenal JH, Murphy LM (1965). Long-term survivors in acute leukemia. Cancer Research 25:1491-1494.
Carpenter A (1880). The treatment of leucocythaemia. Lancet 1:172-173.
Craigie D (1845). Case of disease and enlargement of the spleen in which death took place from the presence of purulent matter in the blood. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 64:400-413.
Cullen P (1811). Case of splenitis acutus in which the serum of the blood drawn from the arm had the appearance of milk. Edinburgh Medical Journal 7:169-171.
Dameshek W, Freedman MH, Steinberg L (1950). Folic acid antagonists in the treatment of acute and subacute leukemia. Blood 5:898-915.
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (2010). Who was Sidney Farber? Sidney Farber, MD:
A career driven by the power of an idea. Online: http://www.dana-farber.org/About-Us/History-and-Milestones.aspx#Who_was_Sidney_Farber?
Donné A (1844). Cours de Microscopie. Paris, p 10-12.
Ehrlich P (1877). Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Anilinfarbungen under ihrer Verwendung in der Microskopischen Technik. Archives Mikrochirurgie Anatomischer 13:263-277.
Ehrlich P (1880). Methodologische Beitrage zur Physiologie und Pathologie der verschisdenen Formen der Leukocyten. Zeitschrift Klinische Medizinische 1:553-558.
Farber S, Cutler EC, Hawkins JW, Harrison JH, Peirce EC 2nd, Lenz GG (1947). Action of pteroylglutamic conjugates on man. Science 106:619-621.
Farber S, Diamond LK, Mercer RD, Sylvester RF, Wolff JA (1948). Temporary remission in acute leukemia in children prolonged by folic acid antagonist. New England Journal of Medicine 238:787-793.
Farber S (1949). Some observations on the effect of folic acid on acute leukemia and other forms of incurable cancer. Blood 4:160-167.
Forkner CE (1938). Leukemia and allied disorders. A monograph. New York: Macmillan Co.
Franklin AC, Stockstad ELR, Belt M, Jukes TH (1947). Biochemical experiments with a synthetic preparation having an action antagonistic to that of pteroylglutamic acid. Journal of Biological Chemistry 169:427-435.
Franklin AL, Stokstad ELR, Jukes TH (1947). Acceleration of pteroylglutamic acid deficiency in mice and chicks by a chemical antagonist. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 65:368-370.
Fuller HW (1846). Particulars of a case in which enormous enlargement of the spleen and liver, together with dilation of all the blood vessels of the body were found co-incident with a peculiarly altered condition of the blood. Lancet 2:43-44.
Fuller HW (1850). Encephaloid tumour of the abdomen. Transactions of the Pathology Society of London 4:224-225.
Gilman A (1946). The biological actions and therapeutic applications of the B-chloroethyl amines and sulfides. Science 103:409-436.
Goodman LS, Wintrobe MM, Dameshek W, Goodman MJ, Gilman A, McLennan MT (1946). Nitrogen mustard therapy. Journal of the American Medical Association 132:126-132.
Glasziou P, Chalmers I, Rawlins M, McCulloch P (2007). When are randomised trials unnecessary? Picking signal from noise. BMJ 334:349-351.
Hirsch J (2006). An anniversary for cancer chemotherapy. Journal of the American Medical Association 296:1518-1520.
Hutchings BL, Mowat JH, Oleson JJ, Stokstad ELR, Booths JH, Waller CW, Angier RB, Semb I, SubbaRow Y (1947). Pteroylaspartic acid, an antagonist for pteroylglutamic acid. Journal of Biological Chemistry 170:323-328.
Jacobson LO, Spurr CL, Guzman Barron ES, Smith T, Lushbaugh C, Dick GF (1946). Nitrogen mustard therapy. JAMA 132:263-271.
Jukes TH (1987). Searching for magic bullets: early approaches to chemotherapy — antifolates, methotrexate — the Bruce F. Cain Memorial Award Lecture. Canc Res 47:5528-5536.
Leuchtenberger R, Leuchtenberger C, Laszlo D, Lewisohn R (1945). The influence of ‘folic acid’ on spontaneous breast cancers in mice. Science 101: 46.
Lewisohn R, Leuchtenberger C, Leuchtenberger R, Laszlo D (1944). `Folic acid’, a tumor growth inhibitor. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine 55:204-205.
Merk R (1948) . Die Stickstoffsenfgasbehandlung der Lymphogranulomatose [Nitrogen mustard treatment of lymphogranulomatosis]. Medizinische Klinik 43:629-35.
Minot GR, Buckman TE, Isaacs R (1924). Chronic myelogenous leukemia: age, incidence, duration and benefit derived from irradiation. JAMA 82:1489-1494.
National Academy of Sciences (2010). Curing childhood leukemia: A leap of faith.
Neumann E (1869). Ueber die Bedeutung des Knockenmarkes fur die Blutbildung. Ein Beitrag zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Blutkorperchen. Archives Heilkunde 10:68-102.
Neumann E (1870). Ein Fall von Leukamie mit Erkrankung des Knochenmarks. Archives Heilkunde II:1.
Neumann E (1872). Ein neuer Fall von Leukamie mit Erkrankung des Knochenmarks. Archives Heilkunde 13:502-508.
Papac RJ (2001). Origins of cancer therapy. Yale J Biol Med 74:391–398.
Peto J, Eden OB, Lilleyman J, Richards S (1986). Improvement in treatments for children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: the Medical Research Council UKALL Trials, 1972-84. Lancet 1:408-411.
Pfiffner JJ, Binkley SB, Bloom ES, Brown RA, Bird OD, Emmett AD, Hogan AG, O’dell BL (1943). Isolation of the antianemia factor (Bc) in crystalline form from liver. Science 97:404-5.
Piller GJ (1991). Leukaemia: A brief historical review from ancient times to 1950. British Journal of Haematology 112:282-292.
Pocock SJ (1977). Randomised clinical trials. BMJ 1:1661.
Pui C-H, Campana D, Pei D, Bowman WP, Sandland JT, Kaste SC, Ribeiro RC, Rubnitz JE, Raimondi SC, Onciu M, Coustan-Smith E, Kun LE, Jeha S, Cheng C, Howard SC, Simmons V, Bayles A, Metzger ML, Boyett JM, Leung W, Handgretinger R, Downing JR, Evans WE, and Relling MV (2009). Treating childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia without cranial radiation. New England Journal of Medicine 360:2730-2741.
Rhoads CP (1946). Nitrogen mustards in the treatment of neoplastic disease. JAMA 131:656-658.
Seegers DR, Smith JM, Hultquist ME (1947). Antagonist for pteroylglutamic acid. Am Chem Soc 69:2567.
Simone JV (2006). History of the treatment of childhood ALL: a paradigm for cancer cure. Best Practice & Res Clin Haem 19:353-359.
Southam CM, Craver LF, Dargeon HW, Burchenal JH (1951). A study of the natural history of acute leukemia with special reference to the duration of the disease and the occurrence of remissions. Cancer 4:39-59.
Stokstad ELR (1943). Some properties of a growth factor for lactobaccillus cases. J Bio Chem 149: 573-574.
SubbaRow Y, Angier RB, Bohonos N, Boothe JH, Clark MC, Cosulich DB, Cunningham RW, Daft FS, Fahrenbach MJ, Harned BK, Heinle RW, Hultquist ME, Hutchings BL, Kuh E, Mowat JH, Nelson EM, Nelson HV, Northey EH, Peterson WH, Seeger DR, Semb J, Sickels JP, Sloane N, Smith HD, Smith JM, Spies TD, Stokstad ELR, Totter JR, Waller CW, Welch AD (1946). Folic acid. Annals of the New York Academy of
Tivey H (1952). Prognosis for survival in the leukemias of childhood. Pediatrics 10: 48-59.
US National Institutes of Health (NIH) National Cancer Institute (NCI) Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) Program. SEER*Stat Database: Incidence – SEER 9 Regs Research Data, Nov 2009 Sub (1973-2007) <Katrina/Rita Population Adjustment> – Linked To County Attributes – Total U.S., 1969-2007 Counties, National Cancer Institute, DCCPS, Surveillance Research Program, Cancer Statistics Branch, released April 2010, based on the November 2009 submission.
Virchow R (1845). Weisses Blut. Froriep’s Notizen 36:151-156.
Weatherall D (2001). Introduction. In: Christie DA, Tansey RM, eds. Leukaemia – Transcript of a Witness Seminar held at the Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine at UCL, London, on 15 May 2001. Online: eprints.ucl.ac.uk/14885/1/14885.pdf.
Wills L, Clutterbuch P, Evans BDF (1937). A new factor in the production and cure of macrocytic anaemias and its relation to other haemopoietic principles curative in pernicious anaemia. Biochem J 31:2136-2147.